Review · EDINBURGH
Escape Old Edinburgh with a Thrilling Outdoor Puzzle Trail
Edinburgh’s Old Town becomes your game board in this Burke and Hare mystery trail, where you follow a map, inspect the streets for clues, and open real padlocks with numbers earned along the way. It is part walking tour, part outdoor escape room, and part dark tale of Edinburgh’s past.
I like the clever use of real props and local details, which gives the puzzles more weight than a phone-only scavenger hunt. I also like the private format, since your group can work at its own pace and stop for a coffee or pub break. The tradeoff is the route itself: expect 4 to 5 kilometres, hills, and some crowded spots around the Old Town.
- Burke and Hare theme: Follow a historical murder story through Edinburgh’s Old Town.
- Real locks and props: Solve clues to open a physical box during the trail.
- Private groups: Play with only your own team of 2 to 20 people.
- About two hours: Plan for roughly 4 to 5 kilometres of walking, with time to pause.
- Hosts set the mood: Beth and Julia have been singled out for engaging introductions and in-character performances.
- Prize at the finish: Return the satchel after completing the story and collect your reward.
Starting at Nicolson Square with a Story in Hand

Your experience begins at Escape The Past, in Basement 1 at 25 Nicolson Square, Edinburgh EH8 9BX. It is about a five-minute walk from the Royal Mile, so you can fit the activity into a day of Old Town sightseeing without making a special trip across the city.
At the start, you collect a satchel and receive instructions for the trail. The host explains the story, the equipment, and the latest time for returning the satchel. This opening matters. You are not simply handed a phone and sent off to search for random objects. The introduction gives the group a reason to pay attention to the streets ahead.
Hosts including Beth and Julia have been praised for setting the mood and giving an engaging performance. That theatrical touch suits the subject. The Burke and Hare story is grim, so a lively introduction helps the experience feel like a well-planned game rather than a dry history lesson.
Your group can include 2 to 20 people, and the activity is private. That makes it useful for families, friends, couples, or a small work group. You do not need to worry about being paired with strangers, and you can argue over clues in peace.
Following the Burke and Hare Trail Through Old Town

The central story concerns William Burke and William Hare, whose infamous murders became part of Edinburgh’s dark past. The route uses real places in the Old Town as part of the story, so the city itself supplies much of the setting.
The experience is not a standard guided walk where you follow a leader and listen from start to finish. Instead, you use a map and move between locations, solving puzzles as you go. You will need three kinds of information: items from the satchel, clues found in the urban surroundings, and access to a mobile phone with internet.
That mix is one of the activity’s strongest ideas. You are looking at Edinburgh with a purpose. A doorway, sign, building detail, or bit of local information may matter to the next step. The puzzles encourage you to notice parts of the Old Town you could easily walk past while heading between major sights.
You should not expect every stop to be a grand viewpoint or major monument. Some locations exist because they connect to the story or provide a useful clue. That is the point. This activity takes you beyond the usual Royal Mile checklist and sends you into places that may not otherwise make your plan.
More Puzzle Walks and Quests in the UK
- Fun, Flexible Treasure Hunt Around Manchester with Cryptic Clues & Hidden Gems
★ 5.0 · 253 reviews - Fun, Flexible Treasure Hunt Around York with Cryptic Clues & Hidden Gems
★ 5.0 · 248 reviews - Fun, Flexible Treasure Hunt Around Bath with Cryptic Clues & Hidden Gems
★ 5.0 · 208 reviews
Opening Boxes Instead of Checking Answers on a Screen

The satchel contains physical materials, including a box with padlocks. To progress, you solve clues and work out the numbers needed to open the locks. This gives the trail a satisfying physical goal.
I prefer this kind of puzzle to an experience that happens entirely on a phone. A screen can tell you that an answer is correct, but a real lock gives the group something to handle and celebrate. The props also help the story feel more immediate, especially when the host has already established the tone at the meeting point.
The puzzles are designed to be approachable rather than punishing. You will need to think, but the challenge is not intended to trap you for hours. That makes the activity suitable for groups with mixed puzzle experience. If you have done several indoor escape rooms, you may find the clues fairly gentle. If this is your first outdoor escape activity, that is likely a benefit.
The physical format also gives everyone a job. One person can study the map, another can search the surroundings, and someone else can work on the lock or phone clue. In a larger group, this helps prevent the experience from becoming one person solving everything while everyone else follows behind.
What the Two-Hour Route Feels Like
The stated duration is about two hours, though your actual time can vary. A direct run may take just under two hours, while a group that stops for drinks or food may take about two and a half hours. You are allowed to pause along the way, so you can make the experience part of a relaxed afternoon rather than a timed race.
The route covers around 4 to 5 kilometres. That is a useful detail to take seriously. Edinburgh’s Old Town has slopes, steps, and uneven streets, and the activity involves more walking than a short puzzle session near one attraction.
The hills can be tiring for young children and people with mobility concerns. The provided information says most people can participate, but it does not promise a fully accessible route. If walking on slopes or covering several kilometres is difficult for you, ask the operator for current route details before booking.
Crowds are another variable. A Sunday afternoon in February can be fairly calm, yet popular Old Town areas may still be busy. The puzzle work may slow down if you need to inspect a clue near a crowded street. Give yourself time and avoid treating every minute as a race.
Rain does not automatically end the fun. The activity can operate in wet weather, and the satchel and props are part of the outdoor setup. Still, comfortable waterproof clothing and shoes will make a big difference. Edinburgh weather can turn a pleasant two-hour walk into a tiring one if you are not prepared.
The Local Details Make the Walk Worthwhile

The best reason to choose this experience is not simply the murder theme. It is the way the puzzles send you to parts of Edinburgh you might miss on a normal sightseeing route.
You are not just collecting clues from a printed sheet. You use information in the city around you, then connect it to the story and the objects in your satchel. Along the way, the trail teaches you facts about Burke and Hare and gives some context for the places you visit.
That approach works well for people who have already seen Edinburgh’s main sights. Even if you know the city, the trail can give you a different reason to pause in familiar territory. You may recognise the wider Old Town but notice its streets, buildings, and corners in a new way.
It is also a useful answer to sightseeing fatigue. After a few museums, churches, and historical rooms, a self-guided game changes the pace. You are still learning about Edinburgh, but you are doing it by making decisions and solving problems rather than standing quietly in front of displays.
The subject is dark, so this is not the right pick if you want a gentle, cheerful city walk. The tone is theatrical and connected to murder. The activity uses that material as a mystery framework, but the theme may not suit very young children or anyone who prefers lighter entertainment.
Same streets, a different puzzle:
- York Treasure Hunt Adventure: The Mystery of The Gunpowder Snitch
★ 5.0 · 203 reviews - Fun, Flexible Treasure Hunt Around Oxford with Cryptic Clues & Hidden Gems
★ 5.0 · 202 reviews - Shepton Mallet Prison Escape Room – The Cell
★ 5.0 · 187 reviews - Interactive Jack the Ripper Night Walk: London’s Murder Mystery
★ 5.0 · 171 reviews
How the Private Format Changes the Experience

A private activity gives you control over the pace and the group dynamic. With two people, you will share every clue and decision. With 10 or 20 people, you may want to split tasks so everyone has something to do.
The larger the group, the more important communication becomes. A big team can generate plenty of ideas, but it can also crowd around one lock or miss a clue while several people talk at once. If you are booking for a large party, choose one person to hold the map and keep the group moving.
For families, the moderate puzzle level is helpful. Younger players can search for details, handle props, and contribute ideas without needing advanced code-breaking skills. The hills and walking distance matter more than the puzzle difficulty.
For couples or a small group of friends, the trail offers a more active alternative to a standard guided walk. You can stop when you wish, discuss the clues, and enjoy a drink along the route. Since the activity ends where it starts, you do not need to arrange transport back from a distant finish point.
Well-behaved pets should be suitable, provided dogs remain on a lead. Service animals are allowed. As always with a street-based activity, keep the group aware of traffic, pedestrians, and uneven ground.
Price, Timing, and What You Get for $30.16

At about $30.16 per person, this costs more than wandering the Old Town with a free map, but it offers much more structure. Your fee covers the private game, the satchel, physical props, the host’s introduction, the puzzle design, and a prize after completion.
The value is strongest when your group wants an activity rather than a passive tour. You are paying for a prepared story that connects several parts of Edinburgh, plus the effort of solving a sequence of clues. A coffee or lunch stop can be added without leaving the experience, which makes the price easier to justify as part of a half-day plan.
The value is weaker if you dislike puzzles or want a traditional guide to explain every sight in detail. You will not receive a continuous lecture about Edinburgh’s architecture or a standard point-by-point history tour. The information appears as part of the game.
The activity is usually booked around 11 days ahead, so some advance planning is sensible. You receive confirmation when you book, and the ticket is mobile. Free cancellation is available up to 24 hours before the start time. Cancellations or changes inside that window are not accepted for a refund.
Who Will Enjoy This Edinburgh Activity Most

I would choose this for a group that wants to mix sightseeing with teamwork. It works particularly well for:
- Families with older children who enjoy clues and walking
- Friends looking for something beyond a pub crawl or standard tour
- Couples who like escape rooms but want to spend the afternoon outdoors
- Repeat visitors who have already covered the main Old Town sights
- Small work groups seeking a private activity with a shared goal
I would think twice if your group has limited mobility, dislikes hills, or wants a quiet historical explanation. The route is active, the subject is dark, and the puzzles require attention. You should also avoid booking it as a rushed gap between fixed appointments.
The activity is suitable for most people, but the practical details matter. Wear walking shoes, bring a charged phone with internet access, and allow more than the bare two-hour estimate if you want a relaxed pace or a stop along the way.
Should You Book the Burke and Hare Trail?

Book it if you want to see Edinburgh’s Old Town while doing something with your hands and your brain. The real locks, props, local clues, and private format give the walk a clear purpose, and the prize provides a simple payoff at the end.
The strongest parts are the host-led opening, the carefully themed equipment, and the route through less familiar corners of the Old Town. Beth and Julia have helped make the start feel like part of the story, not just a safety briefing.
Skip it if you want a conventional guided tour, have trouble with 4 to 5 kilometres of hilly walking, or would rather avoid a murder-themed experience. For everyone else, this is a smart way to break up a sightseeing day and see Edinburgh from a more playful angle.
FAQ
Where does the activity start?
It starts at Escape The Past, Basement 1, 25 Nicolson Square, Edinburgh EH8 9BX, UK. The meeting point is about a five-minute walk from the Royal Mile.
Where does the activity finish?
The activity ends back at the Nicolson Square meeting point.
How long does the trail take?
The planned duration is approximately two hours. It can take about two and a half hours if you stop for drinks or other breaks.
How far do you walk?
The trail covers approximately 4 to 5 kilometres through Edinburgh’s Old Town.
How many people can join a private group?
Private groups can include between 2 and 20 players.
Do I need a mobile phone?
Yes. You need a mobile phone with internet access, along with information from the surroundings and items from the satchel.
Can I bring a dog?
The trail should suit well-behaved pets, but dogs must be kept on a lead. Service animals are allowed.
New puzzles around the UK
- Inverness Quest: Self Guided City Walk & Immersive Treasure Hunt★ 4.0 · 5 reviews
- Douglas, Isle of Man: Self Guided Walk & Immersive Treasure Hunt★ 3.5 · 2 reviews
- Adventurous Scavenger Hunt in Hastings by Operation City Quest★ 3.0 · 3 reviews
- The Ghost of Mary Queen of Scots Escape Room★ 5.0 · 24 reviews
- Magicians Heist Private Escape Room in Glasgow★ 5.0 · 23 reviews
- Fun and Flexible Treasure Hunt Around Glasgow with Cryptic Clues★ 5.0 · 9 reviews
- A Walk through Tudor Ipswich Tour and Exploration Game★ 4.5 · 3 reviews
- Edinburgh City of Wizards Exploration Game and Tour★ 4.5 · 3 reviews
Puzzle Walks and Quests, head to head.

Fun, Flexible Treasure Hunt Around Manchester with Cryptic Clues & Hidden Gems
Read our review →
Scholars & Secrets of Cambridge: Self-Guided Puzzle Adventure
Read our review →
Brussels Old Town & Beer Secrets: Self-Guided Puzzle Walk
Read our review →
Witch Hunt on Montjuïc: Self-Guided Puzzle Quest in Barcelona
Read our review →Other lists this game appears in




